For those unfamiliar with Suzanne Collins’ “Hunger Games” trilogy or its cinematic offshoots, the story revolves around a world where 24 teenagers are selected each year to battle to the death for the entertainment of a wealthy capital that the 12 poorer outlying districts support with their labor once tried to overthrow.
Every part of the tournament is marketed nationwide, the
selection of the candidates, the training, the details of their struggles and finally
the deaths in the arena and the glorification of the winners. Collins has said
part of the idea came from the Roman practice of having gladiators fight for
Collins could also have drawn inspiration from Japan’s summer national high school baseball tournament, creating her dystopian arena as a stand in for Koshien Stadium, Japan’s high school baseball mecca.
There, a sport officially recognized place in the national
education system, is showcased, not as education but as mass entertainment.
In Collins’ world the real tragedy is not in the visible arena, but in the less visible system of brutality and authoritarianism that supports it, and the same is true in Japanese baseball. People are riveted to Koshien’s spectacle and care about the winners and losers. To a lesser degree, this is also true for prefectural tournaments, whose champions advance to that national arena.
Behind the scenes
Japan’s tragedy is in the system that supports the arena. At
the elementary and junior high levels, competition mimics the Koshien model in
the form of knockout tournaments in which a single loss equals heartbreak.
Through endless, mind-numbing practice and abuse of pitchers’ arms, boys learn
from a young age that the cost of victory is high and the bill often comes due
in the form of broken bodies.
At the summer nationals, small adjustments have been made for
the potential hazard of playing day after day in sweltering heat, rest days
have been added in the final stages and international tiebreak rules were
introduced in 2018 from the 13th inning to prevent overlong games.
With that, the rule that forced games from 2000 to 2017 to be replayed from the
start after 15-inning ties was abandoned.
But the Koshien ideal that demands maximum effort and commitment
remains ingrained and serves as a beacon informing an entire baseball culture that
losing is hateful and mistakes therefore unacceptable in practice or in games
from the moment a young child puts on a glove for the first time.
In December, Niigata Prefecture’s high school baseball
federation, knowing that too many children were staying away from their sport
when there are safer and less burdensome alternatives to baseball, acted to set
For Niigata’s 2019 spring high school tournament, no player would
be able to take the mound in a new inning after he’d already thrown 100 pitches
in that game. The rule didn’t address practice time, pitching on consecutive
days or affect any competition outside of Niigata, but it was a challenge to
the status quo and to the idea that high school baseball is some kind of sacred
temple that must not be fiddled with.
Niigata’s modest plan generated a tremendous backlash, with almost all of the responses falling into three categories:
- Forcing a team to take its best pitcher out of the game will make public schools with fewer good pitchers uncompetitive, making the spectacle less interesting.
- Batters will train to foul off more pitches to get the opposing starter out of the game, making games boring.
- It would eliminate marathon pitching feats that are a staple of tournament’s lore, crushing — for most pitchers – their lone chance at glory, further reducing the quality of the spectacle.
Some in the public supported the Niigata initiative, but they were drowned out by the chorus – including some from the national federation – that don’t want anyone messing with the ritual human sacrifice.
Japan’s High School Baseball Association authorities didn’t
appreciate a local body overstepping its bounds and announcing rules without
consulting their betters. In February, the national association instructed
Niigata to “reconsider,” and the plan was withdrawn. After Niigata’s bold move
drew praise from Japan Sports Agency chief Daichi Suzuki, the national
association announced a blue-ribbon panel to study reform and health
A reporter who covered the proceedings told a Tokyo
symposium on April 23 about an exchange he had with a national association
executive at the time.
“He told me, ‘How do you know throwing more than 100 pitches
is harmful? What evidence do you have? We are instituting a day off between
games,’” the reporter said. “Is having a rest day between two 150-pitch games really
OK? How can we possibly allow that?”
The Cambio Meeting symposium was the third annual meeting of
a group dedicated to reinvigorating baseball in Japan from at its lowest levels
by promoting education and rules to limit abuses. This year’s principle speaker,
Dr. Kozo Furushima, has performed more than 1,200 surgeries on elbows and
shoulders – mostly belonging to youth baseball.
Furushima told of a patient in junior high school, who had
pitched his youth team to the semifinals of Saitama’s prefectural tournament, and
about how his right elbow was deformed with three different injuries in
comparison with his normal left elbow.
“Because his team couldn’t win if he didn’t pitch, he
pitched every game and had been doing so for four years,” Furushima said. “His
pain had started one week earlier. We needed him to extend his arm as far as he
could for the X-Ray and he couldn’t. Some with the same injuries can’t bend
“Those injuries did not occur one week before. It was
obviously not something that occurred suddenly because he was pitching in pain.
The lesson from that is that just because you’re not in pain doesn’t mean
you’re not hurt and not vulnerable.”
“This young man dreamed of being a pro, and now when I look
at these (pictures of his arm), it makes my head hurt.”
Furushima presented research results that indicated, in declining order, four factors for increased injury among young pitchers.
- Pitching competitively for eight or more months a year, 5.05 times normal
- Frequently pitching with arm fatigue, 4.04 times
- 80-plus pitches per game, 3.83 times
- Throwing fastballs over 85 miles per hour, 2.58 times
One inspiration for the symposium has been regular travel by Furushima and others to the Dominican Republic, a country with a population of less than 11 million that has produced roughly 150 active players in North America with major league experience. Japan, with a population of nearly 127 million, currently has less than 1,000 players playing professionally around the world.
During his time as Lotte Marines manager, Bobby Valentine
was puzzled about why a nation as large as Japan that is so passionate about
baseball and has such high levels of economic and educational achievement and
public safety does not produce more of the world’s best players. Why, he asked,
should America or the Dominican Republic be better at producing baseball
players than Japan?
Furushima, who has performed ultrasound examinations on
youth players in Japan as well as Japan’s Under-12 team, found one reason: injuries
to young players. He examined youngsters in the Dominican and found far fewer
injuries than among Japanese players the same age.
What Furushima and his fellow travelers discovered in the Dominican Republic was a youth baseball environment far removed from the highly pressurized Japanese norm.
Future MLB Hall of Famer Albert Pujols, asked in March about
his baseball training in the Dominican, contradicted one of Furushima’s
assertions that coaches there never yell at players.
“Oh, I got yelled at,” he told Japanese media in Tempe,
Arizona. “But the job of the coach is to not give the kids reason to give up on
sports. They have to treat the boys as individuals, help them grow, encourage
their love for the game.”
Ryunosuke Seno, one of the symposium’s leaders, won national
“Boys League” championships in 1999 and 2000 as manager of Osaka’s Sakai Big
Boys baseball club. Since then, however, he has gone from an old-school hard-ass
coach to reform advocate.
“As manager, I had hard practices, I’d get angry, sometimes use physical punishment. We won a championship and celebrated. It was an exceptionally strong team, and what happened to the players on such a strong team? One would expect players like that to…go on to play pro ball, be good ballplayers. But that wasn’t the case. They quit baseball or got hurt. They were saying, ‘I’m done with baseball. I’m full of it. I’m tired of it.’ Guys were burned out, a lot of them.”
“I thought I’d been coaching correctly. But was carrying out
my duties like that right? A lot of the kids on the championship team quit
playing in high school. When I looked at kids playing on other teams, this guy
hurt his elbow, that guy had surgery or quit. There were an amazing number of
those kids. I began to question the purpose of what I was doing.”
Seno and his colleagues are now advocating rules that will, among other things, limit pitches in games and the amount of time teams are allowed to practice and take those decisions out of the hands of coaches who simply don’t know any other way than the old way.
“If you’re limited to two hours practice, that’s the rule,
not the coach’s fault,” Seno said. “Tomorrow is the final, but because players
can’t pitch on consecutive days, today’s pitcher can’t pitch again. That’s the
fault of the rule, not the manager. But if there are no rules, the managers are
thinking, ‘We want to win, he can pitch.’ And the child will say, ‘OK.’”
“It’s going to take a real long time before coaches realize
you can’t force kids to practice so much. That’s because coaches don’t think
what they’re doing is wrong. If a player is fatigued or in pain, the coach will
ask if they’re OK. But the boys are trained to tough it out. So asking a player
if he’s OK is akin to ordering a soldier in battle to charge.”
Although Niigata’s initiative failed to make concrete
headway, it helped push the conversation. In January, the Japan Rubber Baseball
Association, which oversees school tournaments for elementary, junior high and
girls teams, announced a 70-pitch limit for this year’s national elementary
“That is 100 times more important than the Niigata
proposal,” Seno said.
That’s because while high school ball is the tip of Japan’s
abusive baseball coaching iceberg, and the number of elementary and junior high
school players is shrinking more rapidly than the nation’s declining birth rate,
and eroding the base that high school and pro ball depend on.
“You’d think playing baseball is cheap for kids, but it isn’t,” a long-time youth coach said. “There is a huge burden on parents to come and provide lunches for the long practices, and the medical bills can be extravagant.”
One of the nation’s more progressive teams is the Tokyo
Aoyama Club, which has one national little senior hardball championships for
junior high school boys. Tokyo Aoyama leases its own grounds with a dormitory
an hour drive from Tokyo, where kids practice virtually every day they aren’t
in school. But when they play in tournaments, game experience rather than
victory at all costs is the focus. Pitchers are not allowed to pitch on
consecutive days and their pitch counts are monitored.
Still, the training is Spartan, with lots of running and
strength training and the rules strict.
“They had a 1-kilogram bento rule,” said a woman whose son
played with the club five years earlier. “The wanted you to eat so they could
grow stronger. They would weigh the lunch boxes and if they weren’t heavy
enough, the kids would get sent home.”
“Everyone was forced to eat that huge meal. My son was big,
so it was no problem. But you’d see smaller boys crying because they couldn’t
and then throwing up when they tried.”
At the Cambio Meeting symposium, one speaker who works for
an NPB team, cited rapidly falling numbers of elementary and junior high school
players across the country and predicted that even more high schools would soon
find it difficult to field teams.
“One problem is that Japanese youth baseball is not fun,” he
said. “Grounds are hard to secure, so little time is actually spent playing.
Mostly kids are running. It is demanding and considered hard, and there are
lots of hurdles to entry at the lowest level.”
“It needs to be made something the kids will want to come
back and do more of. It needs to be fun.”
Dr. Furushima, however, said fun is not the old-school
“The old way is to shout at the boys and even hit them when
they don’t do something the right way. But little boys who’ve never really
played aren’t good at it when they start, so of course they make lots of
mistakes, so many coaches who think they’re helping and doing the right thing will
yell at them.”
“In high schools, if a pitcher gives up a lot of hits, there
are cases where he is sent to the sidelines to throw a 250-pitch bullpen as
“It really drives home the idea of how little hold the
concept of human rights has in Japan.”