Baseball diversity matters

This winter, as Major League Baseball crosses out everything on its balance sheet that smacks of dead weight in an oligarchic pursuit of higher return on investment has triggered a sense of nostalgia for Japan’s summer of 2004, when Japan’s owners got the bit between their teeth and did their best to euthanize its less successful Pacific League.

That spring, one of the PL’s founding ownership groups, Osaka’s Kintetsu Railroad, announced it was looking to sell its team. The prospect of a weak five-team PL caused owners to scramble for solutions. The first was a merger between the league’s two Kansai clubs, with the Orix BlueWave absorbing Kintetsu to become the Orix Buffaloes.

But as owners began realizing that 10 clubs was a more sustainable number than 11, teams began looking around for merger partners, while fans and players fretted about an end to the two-league rivalry that had been one of the engines for pro baseball’s popularity.

It didn’t happen because the players went on strike and fans supported them, culminating in a settlement that preserved a six-team PL, and established interleague play.

It was a vastly more complex issue, but the owners took the stance that the game belonged to them, not the fans and certainly not the players, and that the PL was a failed experiment that should be eliminated. Although the death of the PL would have ended the CL as well, nobody saw it like that. It was 100 percent about, “Let’s cut out the inefficiencies.”

That was 16 years ago, and the league that was then treated as a failed experiment is now beating the established “we know how to operate baseball business” league like a drum. The PL is propelling Japanese baseball into the future because, in the summer of 2004, the fans and players saved it. Those fans and players saved Japanese pro baseball from the short-sighted arrogant oligarchic desire to marginalize the weak.

Deciding the value of an organization or group or community based on a straight-line spread sheet analysis of short-term costs ignores so much. Eliminating or marginalizing those who don’t figure in today’s profits, especially when they do things differently, means eliminating diversity from the system. It is the hubris of believing an algorithm creates wisdom.

It is so easy to see those who are different and less profitable as drains on a system. But eliminating or marginalizing baseball leagues because they don’t serve your immediate goals means eliminating their contributions you can’t see or don’t want to see because it conflicts with your algorithm or your belief that you are better than they are.

Baseball leagues matter.

Kotatsu League Dec. 26

No posting in sight for Senga

On Saturday, the SoftBank Hawks held their annual “reject Kodai Senga’s plead to be posted” contract negotiation. The 26-year-old is on track to be a domestic free agent a year from now and eligible to move overseas on his own power after the 2022 season. Since GM Sugihiko Mikasa indicated a multiyear deal was ready for Senga, it seems he turned that down with the hope the club might just change its mind a year from now and post him after four years of head-shaking.

The Hawks have, according to Call to the Pen, signed Cuban pitcher Andy Rodriguez. The Hawks non-tendered pitchers Rick van den Hurk and Matt Moore, but would love to have Moore back for a second season in Fukuoka.

Tigers bulk up

The Hanshin Tigers have reached deals to import two of KBO’s outstanding imports last season, Mel Rojas Jr, and pitcher Raul
Alcantara, signed lefty Chen Wei-yin, who finished the 2020 season with the Lotte Marines, and re-signed closer Robert Suarez.

Alcantara won the 2020 Choi Dong Won Award as KBO’s outstanding pitcher, while Rojas is the second straight KBO RBI leader to join the Tigers following their 2019 acquisition of Jerry Sands. Rojas, the 2020 MVP also led the league in home runs and finished third in batting average.

The Marines have come to terms with infielder Adeiny Hechevarria, the Miami Marlins’ everyday shortstop from 2013 to 2016. Hechevarria has been a utility infielder since, although he did hit a career-high nine home runs last year.

Marines manager Tadahito Iguchi said he expects Hechevarria could hit 20 homers a season in Japan. I thought that was a bit of stretch but two of the 140 players who hit 20-plus HRs in their first NPB season came here without ever hitting more than nine in a year, so it’s not quite as silly as it sounds.

Tender touches

The Marines also brought back Frank Herrmann, whom they non-tendered, for a second season in Chiba, while the Lions have done the same with first-year reliever Reed Garrett. The Orix Buffaloes have also agreed to bring back closer Brandon Dickson for his ninth season.

When I saw Stefen Romero cut after an outstanding first season with the Rakuten Eagles, I wondered if an unusually large number of players were non-tendered this year, but that wasn’t appear the case. The 12 teams cut 132 players on Dec. 2, one shy of the 133 cut in 2016 and 2019.

From 2003 to 2010 the median was 94. Since 2011, the new median is 127.5, with the watershed year being 2011.

This should come as no surprise to anyone. That year, both leagues were thrown into chaos between the introduction of a deader uniform ball, the merging of umpires from both leagues for the first time, and low-lighting for several months in the wake of the nuclear disasters following the March 11 killer earthquake and tsunami. Offense plummeted, many players’ numbers dipped precipitously, and a lot of them got the chop.

Since then 120 to 130 has been the norm, and this year, which at first glance appeared to be a response to more available talent from the frozen free-agent market in the States, is not that unusual.

Free agent market

Speaking of free agents, one team’s international director said he did not feel more veteran major leaguers were looking to a Japan contract this year to escape the majors’ current buyers market.

In the domestic market, Yasuhiro Ogawa, the first pitcher in Japan to throw a no-hitter in the same game he first struck out 10 batters, tested the market as a free agent and decided to stay with the Yakult Swallows rather than join the Pacific League’s Nippon Ham Fighters.