Category Archives: Commentary

The “why” of Roki Sasaki

Roki Sasaki is coming, MLB ready or not.

I’ve talked about the “how,” in “Roki Sasaki’s unprecedented situation,” and you can read about the “what” – as in what he brings – in numerous scouting reports on the net. I’m bigger on his slider than most, and not as big on his fastball and split – although that split has been monstrous in the past and I expect it to rebound going forward.

Today, I’m going to tell you the “why” behind Roki Sasaki.

A posting was always in the cards

We could all guess back in 2019 that Roki Sasaki’s posting was inevitable, although the early timing came as a surprise.

Four teams went after Sasaki in the 2019, with the Pacific League’s Lotte Marines getting his rights by lottery. Japan’s hardest throwing high school pitcher had passed on signing with an MLB team because to do so prior to the summer of 2020 would have meant being classified as a pro prior to his final summer of high school ball and missing out on his shot at pitching in the summer nationals at Koshien Stadium.

Prior to the 2019 draft, it is likely Sasaki told would-be suitors he would only sign with teams willing to post him to MLB, because two teams that called him a generational talent after meeting with him, the Yomiuri Giants and SoftBank Hawks, did not nominate him as their top pick. Both of those clubs have long disparaged the posting system, and the Hawks have never used it, ever.

Why so early?

This is the big question.

By going at the age of 23, Sasaki is forgoing MLB free agency by moving when MLB’s agreement with its union classifies him as an amateur, subject to a minor league deal, six years of team control, and unable to cash in on any substantial income until he becomes arbitration eligible.

Continue reading The “why” of Roki Sasaki

NPB in a more perfect world

By virtue of running one of just two huge pro spectator sports in one of the world’s top economies, there is no reason to believe Nippon Professional Baseball could not possibly rival MLB in terms of quality and depth of talent. It would take time and investment, but there could be a world where Japanese teams attract their share of the world’s top baseball talent and market their games around the globe.

Why NPB is a historical anachronism: “Roki Sasaki and NPB’s rocky road”

Tip of the hat to John Lennon

Imagine a universe in which there was no appreciable difference between the talent depth in NPB and MLB, where the best players from North and Central America and the Caribbean dreamed of playing in Japan because it’s different, and where Japan’s best players were still drawn to MLB for the experience but were just as happy to compete here with American fans tuning in to see the next Shohei Ohtani competing in NPB parks with all their organized chaos.

During the years Bobby Valentine managed in Japan, we frequently shook our heads in amazement that a nation with such a strong economy and robust infrastructure and a love of baseball unsurpassed in the world could lag so far behind MLB.

The simple reason is that NPB has attempted to keep its system anchored in the past, while the outside world has dramatically changed.

How NPB and MLB stack up

MLB develops talent from all over the world, while NPB operates as if its fans want their teams to be purely Japanese, which was probably not even true in the 1960s, when Yomiuri billed its Giants as purely Japanese despite the club’s best pitcher, Masaichi Kaneda, being Korean and its most productive hitter, Sadaharu Oh, Chinese.

Continue reading NPB in a more perfect world