Category Archives: Commentary

The forgotten 4 & miss-translations

For some reason, probably a miss-translation, Japanese pro baseball only counts no-hitters that are also shutouts. Daichi Osera’s gem on Friday., June 7, was the 102nd of those thrown in Japan’s majors during the regular season. I knew of at least one other, but hadn’t done the leg work to identify more. So I was happy to learn that Osera’s no-hitter was actually the 104th individual effort.

This information allows us to correct a sentence that was bandied about a lot last year when Yoshinobu Yamamoto threw his no-hitter. At the time, Kyodo News wrote:

“In September, Yamamoto threw a no-hitter for the second consecutive year, something previously accomplished in 1936 and 1937 by Sawamura and in 1940 and 1941 by Tadashi Kameda.”

While that is true, it is precise only if we limit these three pitchers’ no-hitters only to shutouts… Because the record for consecutive seasons with a no-hitter is not two, but three.

As for why Japan’s rule for counting no-hitters is different from MLB’s, my guess is that a miss-translation on this side likely caused generations of Japanese to believe that only shutouts could be no-hitters. There are at least two precedents for this:

Continue reading The forgotten 4 & miss-translations

MLB’s major-league identity crisis, the Negro Leagues and the world

When you are trying to be something you’re not, trouble follows. Major League Baseball is now walking into trouble with its eyes wide open in regard to America’s Negro Leagues. It is just and proper that in 2020, MLB finally recognized the Negro Leagues as major leagues.

They were always major leagues, and that is not a problem. On Wednesday, MLB created a problem by including Negro League records as MLB records, and that is an issue because it falsely affirms MLB’s ownership of the idea of “major leagues.” The concept of major leagues is that they are at the top of a pro baseball pyramid, but as long as MLB considers itself the gatekeeper of what is and is not a major league, all of its pronouncements are hollow and silly.

Continue reading MLB’s major-league identity crisis, the Negro Leagues and the world